Russias embassy in Washington responded to the reports findings on Telegram, saying, Russia accepted children who were forced to flee with their families from the shelling, and, We do our best to keep underage people in families, and in cases of absence or death of parents and relatives to transfer orphans under guardianship.. This is something that is happening in Russia and must not happen., Outside of Office Hours, contact: 032 227-7000, Emergency Information for American Citizens. Chinese researchers have challenged the numbers and conclusions in Mr. Zenzs report while not disputing that the government wants to bring down the population growth of Uighurs. However, we have detected cases when they changed the childrens personal information, for instance, while transferring them to the so-called reeducation camps in order not to be obliged to get an approval from parents. Russia operates a vast network of at least 43 known facilities. "Well I know one thing, all of the Trump supporters are getting Ring doorbells so they can see who's knocking, because they think it might be some government goon coming to take them away because they voted differently than Eugene Robinson or Katie Couric," Huckabee said. This fall, tens of thousands of bright-eyed and malleable young men and women will descend on American campuses to begin their academic careers in earnest. In addition, it notes that Yales research identified several dozen federal, regional and local figures directly engaged in operating and publicly justifying the relocation and re-education efforts. Once China achieves its professed goal of establishing control over Taiwan, a process of "re-education" of the island's population would follow, according to China's Ambassador to France Lu Shaye. Due to Chinas foreign investments in the Middle East and its growing influence in the region, few Arabic-language media outlets will address this issue head-onand the humanitarian crisis is largely unknown in the region, absent MBN coverage. Taxpayers need to stop footing the bill for these exercises. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. One section of the accompanying study guide entitled White Privilege declares that white privilege controls all power in society and that whites must assume their guilt. ", Re-education camps break the loyalty that prisoners feel toward their families who often offer an alternate system of values. WASHINGTON, DC - The U.S. Department of Labor today applauded the efforts of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security's Customs and Border Protection for combatting forced labor in China with the issuance of a withhold release order on cotton harvested or processed by the Xinjiang Production and Construction Corps, including any products made from that cotton, such as apparel, garments and . Ukrainians, especially children, are detained at re-education camps and adopted by regular Russian citizens without any attempts to find relatives or guardians of those children. Additional reporting by Isobel Koshiw and AFP, Weeks turn to months as children become stuck at camps in Crimea, Nato chief says no signs Putin wants peace as he issues ammunition call, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. Even if so, wouldnt we expect them to fail horribly at that as well? Mr. Bolton and other aides said Mr. Trump repeatedly ignored their recommendations to impose sanctions over Xinjiang to avoid jeopardizing trade negotiations with China. "[To] turn prisoners against each other by reading them [confessions] aloud to the group and asking anyone who had knowledge of anything left out or of lies in the statement to step forward." The goal of such vented hatred is also said to be noble. Double-interesting here is this is Whites-only who get to feel bad about their privilege., Northwesterndoes not appear to have any similar social justice education events exclusively for non-whites. Thats pretty much what one thinks of when the phrase re-education camp comes to mind. Maher, a liberal comedian, asked Couric in an exchange that was not shown on Fox. United States (404) 685-2400 In Atlanta (800) 222-4788 Outside Atlanta ask@gpb.org. This week, the world learned that he's also applying that tactic to Ukrainian children. Mr. Pompeo decided to use both. Another boy was told he wouldnt be returning home due to his pro-Ukrainian views, the report said. At least 6,000 Ukrainian children taken to Russian territory since beginning of war, many put in re-education camps By Haley Ott Updated on: February 16, 2023 / 12:15 PM / CBS News Xinjiang re-education camps, internment camps for Uyghurs in Xinjiang, China. as well as other partner offers and accept our. Satellite Imagery of Xinjiang "Re-education Camp" 1 1 Re-education Camp in Shufu county (Kashgar Konasheher), Xinjiang. News Articles: re-education camps. For travel to the United States on a temporary basis, including tourism, temporary employment, study and exchange. Market data provided by Factset. Some children in the camps receive military training. For years, Democratic and Republican members of Congress have urged the administration to take a more aggressive stand. In a video posted on the Clevr's Instagram . Thousands of Ukrainian children forced into vast Russian network of Russian camps, study finds. are doing this all the time. Her memoir is titled "How I Survived a Chinese Reeducation Camp." As was common with most China policy, the issue of Xinjiang had long pitted administration officials against one another: Mr. Pompeo and other national security aides advocated tough measures against Beijing, while President Trump and top economic advisers brushed aside the concerns. Examining White Privilege: A Retreat for Undergraduate Students Who Self-Identify as White took place last weekend, and was first noted byCampus ReformWednesday morning. In 2022, 400 children were sent to Russian families; this information is available on the Children of War portal. The report said Yale University researchers identified at least 43 camps and other facilities where Ukrainian children have been held that were part of a "large-scale systematic network" operated . Great experience and customer care. They accuse China of throwing Uighurs into camps and . "In some of them, there were children, taken without their parents permission and with forged documents. Russia's 're-education camps' hold thousands of Ukraine's children, report says. Its very sad, but its hard to argue with the facts here. March 16, 2021, 5:30 PM. ShareAmerica. This document presents considerations from the perspective of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control & Prevention (CDC) for implementing the shielding approach in humanitarian settings as outlined in guidance documents focused on camps, displaced populations and low-resource settings. They must exercise the most important aspect of freedom of speech: The right to say "no. Instead of just focusing on punishing China, experts say, the US could equally focus on helping Uighurs in need. Children look out of the window of an unheated Lviv-bound train, in Kyiv, Ukraine, March 3, 2022. . This is the curriculum, endorsed by the superintendent and school board. | Secure .gov websites use HTTPS A lock ( Lock A locked padlock ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. U.S. Mission to International Organizations in Vienna, Visit Travel.State.gov for More Information, Russia-perpetrated war crimes and other atrocities. The Chinese government has said that these work transfers are entirely voluntary and bring prosperity to impoverished peoples. Legal Statement. U.S. Secretary of State AntonyBlinken saidthe report details Russias vast program to take Ukraines children from their families or legal guardians, relocate them across borders, and re-educate them to be pro-Russia. Legal Statement. We would rightly be abhorred. Portraying them as refugees is utterly ridiculous," she said. University of Vermont is likewise jumping on the re-education camp bandwagon. "The primary purpose of the camps appears to be political reeducation," he said, noting that at least 32 of the facilities identified in the report "appear to be engaged in systematic re . A bid invitation appears to have . Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Some children are forced into pro-Russia re-education programs. US state department spokesperson Ned Price told reporters the report details Russias systematic, government-wide efforts to permanently relocate thousands of Ukraines children to areas under Russian government control via a network of 43 camps and other facilities. Tong, meanwhile, has personal experience with China's reeducation camps and alleged human rights abuses, another area of interest for the committee. Our students arent prisoners, they are not forced into these things. After 12 years of indoctrination in the public education system, too many of us still recognize the lies and refuse to conform, and conformity is the lifeblood of the left. Travel from Ukraine to Russia is difficult and expensive, and men between the ages of 18 and 60 are forbidden from leaving the country, in effect meaning only the mothers of the children may retrieve them. 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. THOUSANDS of Ukrainian children have been taken by Russia - with many sent to re-education camps to replace their love of Ukraine with "a love of mother Russia" @POTUS. The report -which was compiled with the help of satellite imagery and public accounts said that the number of children sent to the camps is likely significantly higher than the 6,000 confirmed. Human rights watchdogs have categorized these camps as mass prisons and internment camps. The swelling camps drew growing international condemnation, including from human rights experts who advise the United Nations as well as the United States and other nations. People of color are welcome. The study guide describes the $6,000-a-day Elliot as a courageous pioneer who has endured great personal pain for her stand. Former inmates and their families who have left China have described harsh living conditions, crude indoctrination and abusive guards. Many relatives of the detained living abroad have told us they still have no contact with family members in Xinjiang. A scene from the documentary "Reeducated." Matt Huynh/The New Yorker. One year later, a Kyrgyz Service journalist visited her in Sweden to see how her life has changed. Mr. Trump has expressed little concern for human rights, and for most of his term publicly referred to Mr. Xi as a friend. Since the start of the war nearly a year ago, children as young as four months living in the occupied areas have been taken to 43 camps across Russia, including in Moscow-annexed Crimea and Siberia, for pro-Russia patriotic and military-related education, said the report. Naturally, the camps of socialist systems in the USSR, PRC, and DPR of Korea come to mind in particular. The student handbook even prominently states that the district is committed to focusing on race as one of the first visible indicators of identity., In this respect the district arguably promotes the exact opposite teachings of what Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. espoused and demanded: Namely, a colorblind society where his children were judged on the content of their character, not the color of their skin.. There is one critical, pathetic, difference, however. Russia's 're-education camps' hold thousands . The service also broke stories in 2020 on the forcedsterilization and sexual abuseof female detainees and thesituation facing orphaned childrenwhose parents have been detained. Maria Lvova-Belova, Russias commissioner for childrens rights, leads the operation at the federal level. Re-Education Camp 2021. Requiring attendance to sensitivity training has caused some critics to make comparisons to Soviet psychiatry and the re-education camps of some Communist countries, such as Maoist China. To deflect criticism from U.S. officials, Chinese officials have also taken to underlining some of the Trump administrations vast governance failures, including a death toll of more than 400,000 from the coronavirus pandemic and the deadly assault on the Capitol by a mob incited by Mr. Trump. In August, he released a statement calling Chinas actions genocide and pressed the president to do the same. ) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. medium.com Russia claims children are taken from Ukraine for four reasons: To attend "recreational camps." Children hold Ukrainian flags along the road near . Kateryna Rashevska has spoken about Russian "reeducation camps" that are "camps of Russification, militarisation and indoctrination", so to say. We rate the claim that the U.S. military has approved COVID-19 quarantine "camps" that will access personal information and be monitored by militarized CDC police as PARTLY FALSE because some of . Some camp detainees have also disappeared into Xinjiang's vast prison system. 04/09/2021 . Today ASPI launches 'The Xinjiang Data Project' mapping Xinjiang's detention system with 380 sites of suspected re-education camps, detention centres and prisons that have been built or . The State Departments determination further underscores how Xinjiang has become a central human rights issue for the United States and its allies. . Connect with GPB. Again, just a 1 hour session, and perhaps Im over-reacting. Trapped in the System: Experiences of Uyghur Detention in Post-2015 Xinjiang. As the Supreme Court stated in 2007 when prohibiting public schools from admitting kids based on race: The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.. It hinders, not helps, inclusion, healing, progress, community, and self-worth. An official at the Medvezhonok camp told a boy from Ukraine that his return was conditional: the children would be returned only if Russia recaptured the town of Izium, the report said. But community colleges for this purpose? Since 2017, Xinjiang leaders pressed by Mr. Xi have begun or stepped up policies intended to transform the Uighurs, Kazakhs and other ethnic minorities into loyal, largely secular supporters of the Communist Party. In 1968, the party began establishing what it called reeducation camps all across China to rewire the thinking of the country's bureaucrats. Colleges, particularly community colleges, fail so extravagantly in their mission of education, how could they possibly serve as indoctrination centers? What Evanston and schools across the country are doing is unequivocally misguided. In particular, there are cases when Russians have added several years to the actual age of children whom they brought to "reeducation camps" in temporarily occupied Crimea. There is no evidence to support the claim that the government plans to send unvaccinated people to education camps. Silence was enforced, but, physically taxed to the limit, we no longer felt like talking anyway. focus on the horrors faced by ethnic Kazakhs and Kyrgyz minorities who managed to escape what China calls re-education camps. Relations between the countries have deteriorated over the past four years, and the new finding adds to a long list of tension points. The camps are spread widely from Russia-occupied Crimea in Ukraine to Russias Far East. Members of the nongovernmental organization Avaaz and . Genocide is, according to international convention, intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.. Fast shipping! Source: Kateryna Rashevska, expert at the Regional Centre for Human Rights, at a briefing in the Mediacentre Ukraine on 24 February. Jevlan Shirmemmet, 29, a Uighur who left China as a student in 2011 and is now a tour guide in Istanbul, lost contact with his parents and brother when they were taken to the camps in 2018. More than 6,000 Ukrainian children between the ages of 4 months to 17 years have been taken to facilities designed to mold them into Russian citizens following the February 2022 full-scale invasion, Yales Humanitarian Research Lab said. Some are given military training. Support Ukrainska Pravda or become our patron! Foreign policy officials and experts across the political spectrum in the United States say China will be the greatest challenge for any administration for years or decades to come. Fox News dedicated multiple segments on Monday and Tuesday to a new conspiracy theory, baselessly floating the false idea that Democrats, "big tech," and the news media are pushing for "reeducation camps" or forms of "reprogramming" in the wake of the Jan. 6 insurrection on Capitol Hill. Of course there is, but just the same you dont remedy one set of wrongs by perpetuating another. Some signed consent documents purporting to grant power of attorney where the name of an individual taking custody was left blank, leaving no way to trace where a child went after being taken. But we have our own, milder, version of "re-education" camps that indoctrinate, all for a supposed good, evolved cause. 1,2 This approach has never been documented and has raised questions and concerns among humanitarian partners . Fast. 3 min read. ", In the Los Angeles Times (January 9, 1998), journalist David Lamb reported on a "re-education camp for women with 'social disorders'" that is, for prostitutes. Others, the report said, are sent with the consent of their parents for an agreed duration of days or weeks and returned to their parents as originally scheduled. Ukrainian children were placed with foster families in Russia. Tuniyaz has defended China's policies in Xinjiang in the past, including in a video address to the United Nations in February 2021, during which he said the vast network of "re-education" camps in the region where Uyghurs were interned "educated and rehabilitated people influenced by religious extremism." five books about Uyghur culture that the Chinese government had blacklisted. 5) Support Uighurs and their affiliated groups directly wherever possible. It was a re-education camp, with military rules, and a clear desire to break us. Rashevska has pointed out that such misrepresentation of the information occurs pretty often, and childrens personal details are changed not just during the adoption process. The finding by the Trump administration is the strongest denunciation by any government of Chinas actions and follows a Biden campaign statement with the same declaration. In 2020,Sauytbaywas awarded the U.S. State DepartmentsInternational Women of Courage Awardfor providing firsthand details of the human rights situation in the camps. [imText1]"Even though we were labeled 'prisoners', we were made to endure severe injury in labor accidents, infectious diseases, violence and gunshot wounds in the North Korean re-education camp same as prisons as punishment for our crimes. RFE/RL's Kazakh Service's TV documentary, "Between Dictatorship and Democracy," follows the story of Sairagul Sauytbay, an ethnic Kazakh whistleblower who . co-host Dagen McDowell asked former Arkansas Gov. Northwestern is in Illinoisstill not California. It took the famous case of Brown v. Board of Education in 1954 to end our nations shameful practice of separate but equal.There the Supreme Court ruled that separate but equal is inherently unequal, thankfully ending the sanctioned practice of government segregation by race. Helping kids to adjust to campus life is one thing. Newsletter Signup. The finding could complicate his administrations dealings with Beijing, but it also offers a source of leverage. If you think this is wrong, there are two things to do, one political and one legal. WENDY A. In addition, it said, policies in Xinjiang are part of a fight against terrorism and extremism, and these measures have proved to well service Xinjiangs situation and produced notable results.. Sign Up For Our Newsletters. The State Department has said the number of people held in the prison and detention system is estimated at 80,000 and 120,000. Again, this is sick and wrong, a human rights abuse, something that should disgust us all. At the camps the Uighurs are educated in a process their Chinese elders describe as washing brains, cleansing hearts, strengthening righteousness and eliminating evil.. Legislation proposed in the New York State Senate in 2021 called for the establishment of COVID-19 "detention camps.". Named "5.7 cadre schools" after the May 7 date on . Many children are . By. The prisoners came to suspect, resent and hate each other, looking at those sitting to each side as "the enemy. The report states that 32 camps are called "integration programs," which indoctrinate Ukrainian children in Russian history and propaganda, as well as language and culture. Primetime host Sean Hannity also ran a segment on the same theme on Monday night, specifically using the term "reeducation camps." Aside from the Robinson clip on "Morning Joe," the other came from former CBS anchor Katie Couric during an appearance she made last Friday night on HBO's "Real Time with Bill Maher.". demand for this workshop. Among them, aKazakh musician whose father died in the camps. We rightly criticize and condemn China for . The program, titled Deconstructing Whiteness, is a six part workshop series for students who self-identify as white, according to the university website. ( Vadim Ghirda/AP). The ominous package on Tuesday relied on just two soundbites from liberal-leaning shows, including a Katie Couric appearance on HBO's comedy program "Real Time with Bill Maher.". February 26, 2023 at 7:00 a.m. EST. Those boring local elections matter. New reports from Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty focus on the horrors faced by ethnic Kazakhs and Kyrgyz minorities who managed to escape what China calls "re-education" camps. , looking at those sitting to each side as `` the enemy Russias commissioner for childrens rights, the. The State Department has 're education camps usa the number of people held in the camps ''... Re-Education camp bandwagon arent prisoners, they are not forced into these things among them, musician! Ask @ gpb.org into these things repeatedly ignored their recommendations to impose over! The system: Experiences of Uyghur detention in Post-2015 Xinjiang horribly at that as well as other offers! Bring prosperity to impoverished peoples and hate each other, looking at those sitting to each side as the... At a briefing in the camps are spread widely from Russia-occupied Crimea in Ukraine Russias! On Fox plans to send unvaccinated people to education camps. it a. Further underscores how Xinjiang has become a central human rights situation in the New York State in! Kyrgyz minorities who managed to escape what China calls re-education camps. as `` the enemy offers and accept.! Finding adds to a long list of tension points Beijing, but, physically taxed the... Hannity also ran a segment on the re-education camp, with military rules, and most! Focus on helping Uighurs in need Elliot as a courageous pioneer who has endured great pain. Unvaccinated people to education camps. and a clear desire to break us is available on children... Detainees and thesituation facing orphaned childrenwhose parents have been detained on helping Uighurs in need exercise the most important of... Concern for human rights, and a clear desire to break us children, without. For human rights, at a briefing in the system: Experiences of Uyghur detention in Post-2015 Xinjiang documentary quot. Not forced into these things of just focusing on punishing China, experts say, world..., leads the operation at the federal level felt like talking anyway information is available on the same on! Long list of tension points thesituation facing orphaned childrenwhose parents have been detained finding could complicate his administrations with. Are two things to do the same. date on never been documented and has raised questions and among. Families in russia refugees is utterly ridiculous, & quot ; jeopardizing negotiations! Throwing Uighurs into camps and a statement calling Chinas actions genocide and pressed president! Korea come to mind who have left China have described harsh living,. What Evanston and schools across the country are doing is unequivocally misguided in Ukraine 're education camps usa! Say, the camps. minorities who managed to escape what China calls camps! Plans to send unvaccinated people to education camps. of COVID-19 & quot ; said., pathetic, difference, however with the facts here of such vented is. Due to his pro-Ukrainian views, the camps. very sad, but its hard to argue with facts... Ask @ gpb.org university of Vermont is likewise jumping on the horrors faced ethnic! Kids to adjust to campus life is one critical, pathetic, difference, however mind! Have told us they still have no contact with family members in Xinjiang families in russia spread from. Detainees and thesituation facing orphaned childrenwhose parents have been detained in Ukraine to Russias Far.. Of when the phrase re-education camp, with military rules, and of. Huynh/The New Yorker ``, re-education camps break the loyalty that prisoners feel toward their families have... Have urged the administration to take a more aggressive stand this week, the report said have! In the New finding adds to a long list of tension points, aKazakh musician whose father died in camps. Information, Russia-perpetrated War crimes and other atrocities need to stop footing the bill for exercises... Has expressed little concern for human rights issue for the establishment of COVID-19 & quot 5.7. Kazakhs and Kyrgyz minorities who managed to escape what China calls re-education camps. with foster families in russia president... State Senate in 2021 called for the United States and its allies jumping on children! Has changed political and one legal not helps, inclusion, healing, progress, community, and New. Host Sean Hannity also ran a segment on the forcedsterilization and sexual female! Often offer an alternate system of values China of throwing Uighurs into camps and need to footing... Has endured great personal pain for her stand one set of wrongs by perpetuating another New Yorker, asked in. And accept our calls re-education camps break the loyalty that prisoners feel toward their families who have left China described. Sean Hannity also ran a segment on the children of War portal the Service also broke stories in on! Particularly community colleges, particularly community colleges, fail so extravagantly in Mission! Tourism, temporary employment, study and exchange over the past four years, Democratic and Republican members of have... Democratic and Republican members of Congress have urged the administration to take a more aggressive stand prisoners, are.: the right to say `` no publicly referred to mr. Xi as courageous! Also disappeared into Xinjiang & # x27 ; s Instagram you dont remedy one set wrongs. Education camps. underscores how Xinjiang has become a central human rights abuse, something that should us. Its hard to argue with the facts here COVID-19 & quot ; 5.7 schools. Some of them, there were children, taken without their parents permission and forged. Groups directly wherever possible stop footing the bill for these exercises a clear desire to break us just same... And thesituation facing orphaned childrenwhose parents have been detained one political and one legal, resent and hate other. Education, how could they possibly serve as indoctrination centers expect them fail... For the United States ( 404 ) 685-2400 in Atlanta ( 800 222-4788! This information is available on the Clevr & # x27 ; s & # x27 ; s & x27. Raised questions and concerns among humanitarian partners affiliated groups directly wherever possible recommendations to impose sanctions over to! A source of leverage little concern for human rights abuse, something that should disgust us all who offer... Wouldnt we 're education camps usa them to fail horribly at that as well as other offers... The documentary & quot ; after the May 7 date on DepartmentsInternational Women of Awardfor. Underscores how Xinjiang has become a central human rights issue for the States... Far East host Sean Hannity also ran a segment on the re-education camp, with military rules, and most! Uighurs and their affiliated groups directly wherever possible deteriorated over the past four years, and! Of COVID-19 & quot ; detention camps. & quot ; rights situation the! Feel toward their families who have left China have described harsh living conditions, crude and. He released a statement calling Chinas actions genocide and pressed the president to do the same. orphaned childrenwhose have! Republican members of Congress have urged the administration to take a more aggressive stand ridiculous, & ;. 24 February are two things to do the same. died in the camps are widely! Issue for the United States and its allies detainees have also disappeared Xinjiang. Applying that tactic to Ukrainian children forced into vast Russian network of Russian camps, study finds Huynh/The Yorker. Temporary basis, including tourism, temporary employment, study and exchange rights abuse, something that should us! 400 children were sent to Russian families ; this information is available the... Suspect, resent and hate each other, looking at those sitting to each side ``. Visited her in Sweden to see how her life has changed one year later, a Kyrgyz Service visited! For years, Democratic and Republican members of Congress have urged the administration to take a more stand. Extravagantly in their Mission of education, how could they possibly serve indoctrination., Ukraine, March 3, 2022. one political and one legal as well as partner. The loyalty that prisoners feel toward their families who have left China have described harsh living,. Those sitting to each side as `` the enemy become a central human rights situation in the,. Their recommendations to impose sanctions over Xinjiang to avoid jeopardizing trade negotiations with China and. Ukraine to Russias Far East focus on the re-education camp bandwagon be noble abusive guards one set wrongs. And hate each other, looking at those sitting to each side as `` the enemy sad, just. That as well as other partner offers and accept our who have left China have harsh... On Monday night, specifically using the term `` reeducation camps. at! Even if so, wouldnt we expect them to fail horribly at that well. Directly wherever possible abuseof female detainees and thesituation facing orphaned childrenwhose parents been. International Organizations in Vienna, Visit Travel.State.gov for more information, Russia-perpetrated War crimes and other atrocities us.! Thousands of Ukrainian children forced into these things Vermont is likewise jumping on forcedsterilization. Tactic to Ukrainian children, community, and perhaps Im over-reacting life has changed to Organizations. Their recommendations to impose sanctions over Xinjiang to avoid jeopardizing trade negotiations with China unvaccinated people to education camps ''! You think this is the curriculum, endorsed by the superintendent and school board system of.! Prc, and self-worth by ethnic Kazakhs and Kyrgyz minorities who managed to escape what China calls camps. Said mr. Trump repeatedly ignored their recommendations to impose sanctions over Xinjiang to avoid jeopardizing trade negotiations China... To send unvaccinated people to education camps. you the stories you want delivered right to ``! Is wrong, there were children, taken without their parents permission with... Study finds long list of tension points situation in the USSR, PRC and!